Menu | Rating System | Guest Book | Archived Reviews:
A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z

         
       
         
 
Recording:
  The Jerks Win Again  
 
Artist:
  The Karl Hendricks Trio  
 
Label:
  Merge  
 
Release Date:
  29.July.2003  
 
Reviewed by:
  PostLibyan and Tracers  
         
 
Rating:
   
         
 
Brendan's Introduction:
 

My Minions have so many quirks that sometiems it's not even funny. One of them revolves around Karl Hendricks, a singer-songwriter from Pittsburgh, and several of them going out of their way to track him down at the Merge Records 10th Anniversary Festival.

Anyway, he's got a new album, and here are PostLibyan and Tracers thoughts on it.

 
         
 
Tracers:
  Overall, it's Karl. Musically I don't think he's grown much with this album. If you line all his releases up end to end to end and there is a consistency. As usual, there are some great song titles on The Jerks Win Again. However, this album doesn't seem as bitter as some of his others.  
         
 
PostLibyan:
  Well, before i get into an overall statement on the disc, i like to go over the tracks. Here are my thoughts on the songs here. First up, Chuck Dukowski Was Confused. This song totally rocks. Karl is singing his heart out and his guitarwork is great. All around, this is one of the best rockers i have listened to in quite some time.  
         
 
Tracers:
  Damn straight. I like this one a lot myself. Plus you've got to like anything with Chuck Dukowski in it.  
         
 
Brendan:
  For those of you who are staring blankly at your monitor now, Chuck Dukowski was a bassist with Black Flag. They were a punk band in the 80's. If you don't know them by all means go do some research now. Chuck did in fact, "write the best song on Damaged" as Karl points out.  
         
 
PostLibyan:
 

Track two is New Wave Situation, which is a cool title. The song is decent and i have no real comments on it.

Next is The Night Has No Eyes, and this song gets old. It is just too long, and my advice to Karl is "chill it with the guitar freakouts already". Sheesh.

Then comes The Overweight Lovers. I like this song, but i don't want to. I mean, i'm not the sveltest person in the world, and this song paints the picture of unhappy lonely fat people. I hate the use of the easy stereotype. But, it is a catchy song with good drumming.

 
         
 
Tracers:
  It reminds me a lot of the mopey-ness of the Misery and Women album, combined with the fuller sound of...what was the one with Nogales by Tuesday?  
         
 
PostLibyan:
  That would be 1996's For A While It Was Funny, which i think is Karl's most recent album, before this one of course.  
         
 
Tracers:
  Yeah, that one. There is a sonic similarity.

But you're right i like this song, and you're also right that I don't necessarily want to like it.

 
         
 
PostLibyan:
  Then comes one we can all enjoy shamelessly, I Think I Forgot Something - My Pants. This is a damned funny song with wacky lyrics. Everytime he sings "I think I forgot something / My pants" i chuckle because it is so unexpected. All that plus the song features strong rhythm and nice guitar.  
         
 
Tracers:
  Did you notice on the credits that he gives credit for song titles to various
people?
 
         
 
PostLibyan:
  No, i missed that.  
         
 
Tracers:
  Well, one of the people he credits is his daughter, who I think is still a toddler. I think this may be the song inspired by his daughter. That would make sense, don't you think?  
         
 
PostLibyan:
  I guess so.  
         
 
Tracers:
  It's the only song title that would make sesne coming from a toddler. Of course the idea of toddler talking about Chuck Dukowski is also hysterical in and of itself....  
         
 
PostLibyan:
 

True, but if any kid is going to know her Black Flag, it's bound to be Karl's daughter!

Anyway, up next is Thank God We Have Limes, and much like the second track, i love the title, but the tune is a kind of generic. Contrast this with The Ballad Of Bill Lee, which is a fun catchy tune. How can you not like a song that starts with the line "They called me a commie fag"?

And then finally, after a mere 8 tracks, Karl wraps it up with The Summer Of Warm Beer. There is a painfully long guitar hero style solo in the middle that more or less dominates this song. When the melody comes back it's a good little pop song with Karl's typical great lyrics. I especially like the line "I'm the crown prince of bailing water from an already sinking ship". However, that solo. Ugh. It ruins it for me.

 
         
 
Tracers:
  Yeah you're right about the guitar parts, but i lie the poppinesss of it.  
         
 
PostLibyan:
  It's a decent song, but it just gets tiring in the middle. Reminds me of Band of Susans, who did some great stuff but often lost me during the guitar freakouts. This is opposed to Sonic Youth or Landing, who do not lose me during the guitar freakouts.  
         
 
Tracers:
  That's a product of innovation/not sounding like anything else. Karl's guitar solos have a certain "by the numbers" quality. I also hear it in some of the drumming, but since he doesn't have the "drum solo" thing, it isn't as distracting. I find that the rote-ness of the music seems to have a direct correlation with the amout of confession in the singer/songwriter genre. It's like you can either be creative with the music or creative with the lyrics, but rarely can someone be both.  
         
 
PostLibyan:
 

Ooh! Good one. We'll call this "Tracer's Law of Conservation of Singer/Songwriter Innovation". And it makes sense to me in this contect. It seems like Karl is insisting on "normal rock song structure" which makes things seem slightly formulaic, and does tend to drag the length of a song out. Think about it -- there are fewer songs on this disc than on any other Karl album.

Now for a few overall comments. Firstly, in a way, this is confessional singer-songwriter stuff: folk music really. Except that it is with electric guitar (and Karl apparently just got a new fuzz pedal) and lots of drumming. There is a reflective tone to the lyrics, but the instrumentation is more forceful.

 
         
 
Tracers:
  I think you're right about that confessional aspect of it, but that's always been a Karl trademark. What is different is that the songs here do have more of a tradional "rock" strcuture, which makes some of them seem too long. I contrasted this to one of my favorite Karl songs, Romantic Stories from the War (off Misery and Women). That's a very very long song (i think 5 or 6 minutes), but since it doesn't have the requisite guitar solo, etc., it seems much shorter. Does that make sense?  
         
 
PostLibyan:
 

Yeah, that does make sense.

Okay, another point i want to make is that, listening to this album i hear an influence in Karl that i have not heard before. And this is the much revered Billy Bragg. Karl's guitarwork (especially on <i>Chuck Dukowski Was Confused</i>) and general song writing show a slight bit of Braggishness. This is a good thing, really.

 
         
 
Tracers:
  Good point. I hear that really well on The Ballad of Bill Lee.  
         
 
PostLibyan:
  Overall, i would give The Jerks Win Again a 4. It breaks no new ground, and in fact gets a little tiring at 2 points, but there are some good songs on here.  
         
 
Tracers:
  Yup, I'd agree. It's got more of the same, as I said before. But for me more of the same equals pretty durn good.  
         
 
Related Links:
 

none available.

 
         

Return to the top of this page. | Return to the Album Review menu.